Collection: Goat Cheese
Made in Northern Ohio's Amish country using traditional small-batch methods, our goat milk cheeses are firm and sliceable — a world away from the soft, crumbly goat cheese most people are familiar with. Tangier and lighter than cow's milk, but with all the rich, authentic flavor you'd expect. From mild everyday varieties to bold pepper jack and sharp white cheddar, there's something here for every taste.
-
Goat Brick
Creamy goat milk Brick cheese—melts well for sandwiches, burgers, easy meals.
8 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(8) 8 total reviews
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD -
Goat Colby Longhorn
Mild goat milk Colby—sliceable, snackable, great for family boards.
No reviewsRegular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USDSold out -
Goat Farmers
Mild, creamy goat milk Farmers cheese—perfect for slicing, melting, snacking.
3 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(3) 3 total reviews
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD -
Goat Marble
Goat milk Marble blend—mild, creamy, and versatile for boards and melts.
3 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(3) 3 total reviews
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD -
Goat Mild White Cheddar
Mild, creamy goat milk white cheddar—perfect for snacking, lunch slices.
1 review5.0 / 5.0
(1) 1 total reviews
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD -
Goat Monterey Jack
Smooth, creamy goat milk Jack—perfect for tacos, quesadillas, melting.
2 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(2) 2 total reviews
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD -
Goat Pepper Jack
Goat milk Pepper Jack with gentle kick—perfect for tacos, grilled cheese.
No reviewsRegular price $7.75 USDRegular priceSale price $7.75 USD -
Goat Sharp White Cheddar
Sharp, tangy goat milk white cheddar—perfect for crackers, bold bites.
No reviewsRegular price $8.60 USDRegular priceSale price $8.60 USD -
Goat Yogurt Cheese
Tangy, creamy goat yogurt cheese—perfect for spreading with fruit, honey.
No reviewsRegular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD
Browse Other Collections
-
Traditional Cheese
Since 2008, we've partnered with Amish and small family-run producers in Northern...
-
Grass-fed Cheese
Handcrafted from milk sourced from pasture-raised cows in Northern Ohio's Amish country,...
-
Goat Cheese
Made in Northern Ohio's Amish country using traditional small-batch methods, our goat...
-
Amish Gifts
Handcrafted Amish cheeses, thoughtfully assembled and shipped fresh — whether you're sending...
-
Snack Sticks & Sausages
Satisfy your cravings with our delicious selection of smoked beef sticks, summer...