Welcome to Simply Cheese, where passion for cheese meets tradition, quality, and community. We're not just another cheese retailer; we're a celebration of artisanal craftsmanship and a testament to the unique qualities that set our Amish products apart from the rest.

Our Story

Simply Cheese was born out of a deep appreciation for the art of cheese-making and our dedication to supporting local Amish farmers. We've forged a strong partnership with a farmer-owned coop in Northern Ohio's picturesque Amish country, where each farm has 20 cows or less, and where every cow is lovingly hand-milked. Our journey began with a simple idea: to share the extraordinary flavors and stories behind Amish cheese with cheese enthusiasts like you.

What Sets Us Apart

Natural Purity

Natural Purity

Our commitment to purity and simplicity is unwavering. Our Amish cheeses are made with minimal, all-natural ingredients. No additives, no artificial flavors, no hormones—just pure, authentic cheese.

Handcrafted Excellence

Handcrafted Excellence

At Simply Cheese, we believe that the finest cheese comes from the hands of skilled artisans. Our Amish cheeses are meticulously handcrafted in small batches, ensuring every batch is a masterpiece of flavor and quality.


Time-Tested Tradition

We honor the rich traditions of Amish cheese-making. Each block of cheese is a blend of heritage, craftsmanship, and dedication, resulting in a taste that's steeped in tradition.

Regional Flavors

Unique Regional and Seasonal Flavors

Explore the diverse flavors of Amish cheese with our curated collection. From rich, moist Cheddar and tangy goat cheese to amazing aged Parmesan and spicy Habanero, each variety tells a unique regional story.

Local Communities

Supporting Local Communities

By choosing Simply Cheese, you're not only indulging in exquisite cheese but also supporting local Amish communities and sustainable practices. Our partnership with a farmer-owned coop in Northern Ohio ensures that every purchase supports small-scale farmers who care for their land and animals.

Our Promise

We are committed to providing you with exceptional service and a cheese selection that will delight your taste buds. Quality, flavor, and service are our top priorities, from the moment the milk is delivered to the dairy to when the cheese arrives at your doorstep. If there is a problem with delivery or with the quality or condition of your cheese, we will refund or reship, no questions asked.