> Traditional Cheese

These wonderful Amish cheeses come from one of the few remaining farmer-owned Amish co-ops, which includes approximately 120 members, nearly all of whom are Amish. Each small farm is a labor of love, consisting of no more than 20 cows. Hand-milking is the norm, and the fresh milk is delivered to the USDA-approved Amish-run cheese plant in traditional 10-gallon milk cans. These cows are not treated with BST growth hormones, are not fed GMO feed, and are kept in good health in comfortable environments. From early spring to late fall, the cows are out on pasture, enjoying the luscious grass and sunshine.

Certified non-GMO, Kosher and Halal vegetable rennet is used in these cheeses, rather than animal rennet. The result of all this is an exceptional local cheese, bursting with wholesome flavor, and free of artificial hormones or steroids.

 

Colby Longhorn

Similar in flavor to Cheddar, Colby Cheese is a stirred-curd cheese made with pasteurized milk, like Monterey Jack. Colby cheese has a slightly higher moisture content than cheddar, giving it a softer texture and a mellow, buttery flavor.

$3.50 - $29.00
Asiago

Asiago is an aged cow's milk cheese that has a crumbly texture with a flavor reminiscent of Parmesan. This wonderful cheese is often grated in salads, soups, pastas, and sauces.

(1)
$3.80 - $33.00
Brick

Brick Cheese is a full milk brick with a creamy texture and buttery flavor. Perfect shredded on pizza or toasted on Italian bread.

(3)
$3.50 - $29.00
Sharp White Cheddar

Sharp White Cheddar Cheese is the same as the Sharp Colored but without the Annatto coloring. Its rich, pungent flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.

(1)
$4.50 - $39.00
Marble Pepper Jack

Marble Pepper Jack Cheese blends Monterey Jack with Colby and adds the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates.

$3.50 - $29.00
Parmesan

This Middlefield Parmesan Cheese is out of this world! It is crazy good. It has a medium to hard texture, and is great for shredding onto salads and pasta dishes, as a topping for pizzas, or just for eating by the slice (but make them thin, because this is a strong, delicious, slightly salty cheese).

(5)
$3.80 - $34.00
Fiesta Cheddar

Fiesta Cheddar cheese is one hot cheddar! This is a mild colored cheddar infused with jalapeño peppers.

(1)
$3.80 - $33.00
Buffalo Jack

Try this exciting flavored Monterey Jack cheese! This cheese is full of buffalo wing flavor, and is hot and spicy.

$3.80 - $33.00
Fresh Cheese Curds

Cheese Curds are squeaky fresh, delectable cheddar cheese in its natural, random shape and form before being processed into blocks of cheddar. Their flavor is mild with about the same firmness as cheese, but they have a slight rubbery texture

(4)
$3.50 - $225.00
Cracker Pack

This Cracker Pack includes four cheeses: Cheddar, Colby, Marble, and Monterey Jack. Makes a great gift.

$3.60 - $30.00
Sharp White Cheddar

Sharp White Cheddar Cheese is the same as the Sharp Colored but without the Annatto coloring. Its rich, pungent flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.

$4.50 - $39.00
Smoked Cheddar

Smoked Cheddar Cheese is infused with natural hardwood smoke to produce the distinctive flavor of this uniquely delicious cheddar.

$3.70 - $32.00
Smoked Pepper Jack

Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese is naturally smoked Monterey Jack cheese with Jalapeño peppers.

$3.70 - $32.00
Horseradish Cheese

Horseradish Cheese is rich in flavor, with a subtle nuance of horseradish. This gourmet Monterey Jack cheese is delightful on its own, or perfect for cooking, snacking, and positively excellent on sandwiches.

(2)
$3.80 - $33.00
Habanero

Habanero Hot Cheese is a dramatic flavor blending of savory mellow monterey jack with the spice of Habanero creating a fiery combination.

(3)
$3.50 - $29.00
Veggie Jack

Veggie Jack Cheese is a Monterey Jack cheese blended with veggies! It has a crumbly texture and a pungent flavor. Wonderful!

$3.70 - $33.00
Pepper Jack

Pepper Jack Cheese is Monterey Jack cheese with the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates.

(1)
$3.50 - $29.00
CoJack Marble

Colby Jack Cheese is the delightful result of wedding Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses.

(5)
$3.50 - $29.00
Farmers

Farmers Cheese is delightfully basic and uncomplicated. It is a fresh, mild cheese with a slightly tangy taste, and a texture that is moist, yet dry enough to be sliced.

(1)
$3.50 - $29.00
Monterey Jack

Monterey Jack has no added color and has a smooth, understated yet distinctive flavor that makes it perfect as a topping to virtually any dish.

$3.50 - $29.00
Mild Colored Cheddar

Mild Colored Cheddar Cheese is almost a medium Cheddar. Solid in texture, and very smooth, it is great on sandwiches, apples and crackers, or just for snacking.

$3.50 - $29.00
Mild White Cheddar

Mild White Cheddar Cheese is almost a medium Cheddar. Solid in texture, and very smooth, it is great on sandwiches, apples and crackers, or just for snacking.

(1)
$3.50 - $29.00