Traditional Cheese

These wonderful Amish cheeses come from one of the few remaining farmer-owned Amish co-ops.

Cheese Curds

Cheese Curds are squeaky fresh, delectable cheddar cheese in its natural, random shape and form before being processed into blocks of cheddar.

Grass-Fed Cheese

For the Amish farmers who contribute the milk for our grass-fed cheeses, living off the land is a way of life.

Goat Cheese

Our goat cheeses come from a group of small, local dairy farmers in western Pennsylvania and northeast Ohio. These Amish farmers believe in sustainable agriculture, and they take care of their land and animals.

Swiss Cheese

Featuring Guggisberg Baby and Premium Swiss cheeses, along with a low-sodium and smoked variety.

Other Cheese

These are non-Amish cheeses that we carry for our customers' convenience.

Country Roll Butter

The delicious, creamy, salted or unsalted butter from Alcam Creamery is unlike anything you've ever tasted. Perfect on bread, in cooking, and for eating by the slice.

Gift Baskets/Boxes

Amish cheese (and other delicious products) makes a great gift, especially during the holidays. Choose one or more of these Amish Gift Boxes to send to your friends, family, neighbors, co-workers, or that special someone. They will love it!

Baking Mixes

Fowler's Mill prodcuts are made from grains that are ground between two stones. This slower method of milling enables the grains to remain cool, resulting in flours that retain their high nutritional value and flavor. Stone-ground whole-grain flours and meals contain the three major grain components - bran, endosperm and germ - providing wholesome fiber, vitamins and minerals for maximum nourishment.


Located in Middlefield, Ohio, the Miller family uses the same jam-making process the Amish community has used for generations.

Maple Syrup

Pure Maple Syrup in a round metal tin at a great price. It doesn't get any better than that.


Wonderful, all-natural, pure clover honey.


Bologna, summer sausage, or beef sticks--everyone's favorites!


Mrs. Miller's all natural vegetable noodles offer an exciting alternative to plain pasta noodles.


Insulated Cartons

Add an insulated carton to your order to be sure cheese and butter arrives fresh during the warmer months.